Indiarace.com - india's first & foremost horse racing portal

Topic Details

Back to lists

Tamil Nadu Government V/s Madras Race Club

By Little Tom | 14-Sep-2024

TAMIL NADU GOVERNMENT
V/S
MADRAS RACE CLUB

Coin has two sides:

On the prima facie, Tamil Nadu Government proposal of cancelling the leased land to Madras Race Club on the expiry of leasing period cannot be argued.  Govt. stand is totally correct, even in Court. This is in the case of leased land. But at the same time, it has no loco standi to stop the on going horse racing, since there is a judgement against the Tamil Nadu Government in the court during 1980s - Kalaingr Karunanidhi period - Court dismissed the plea of the Tamil Nadu Government to ban the horse racing. At this juncture, a very big statue of a horse with a jockey was installed on the Mount Road near Gemini Flyover, which is still in existence. This was installed on the pretext that the case would be in favour of Tamil Nadu Government banning the racing.  This was a slap on the then Government.  Perhaps, bearing in this mind, the present Tamil Nadu Government may seek redressal by retrieving the leased land to the Madras Race Club.  Government may also put forth their views that this land would be utilised for public purpose - saying they propose to build a new structure for the Tamil Nadu Secretariat citing examples as that of the New Parliament Building and Amravati for CM Chandra Babu Naidu.  There are also encroachments in the land.

MRC may put forth their argument saying that Govt. has no objection in carrying out the horse racing.  They are concerned about the leased land to be taken aback.  Horse racing is a "Living Industry" compared on par with any manufacturing industry. involving lot of man-power engaged from breeding, training, apart from investments in several crores by owners of horses, breeders, etc. Without the land, this "Living Industry" cannot be carried on continuously, leading to throw out of jobs several personnel in the field of breeding, training of horses and also to pay second thought for the owners of horses for their investment in this "Living Industry".

Court Verdict may be such that -

Tamil Nadu Government's intention is to take back the leased land from MRC.  TN Govt. have no objection to continue horse racing.  MRC wants to continue racing without interruption.  Hence it is prudent to satisfy both the parties, Government must allot an alternate land nearby Guindy to carry on their horse racing activity and till such time status quo should be maintained.

This is purely my personal view.

Viewers views invited.

Post Your reply

3 Replies

Prithviraj Yesudas said ...

14-Sep-2024

Hey Tommie,

Government can't do anything, when the initial lease agreement it was for 100 years, so till 2046 MRC has all the rights to conduct racing. So my advice is for you to chill and enjoy the rest of the weekend, without thinking so much about this issue. 

Gln said ...

14-Sep-2024

This is time punters remember the great human being called MAM  , if the great man was with us today can ant govt touch MRC, RIP legend of Indian racing.

 

Come On said ...

14-Sep-2024

@ Little Tom

Your argument is fine but seems to be the views of a race-goer and not that of a legal luminary.

Why I say this is bcos if that's the case, how did the TN government succeed in abolishing racing at Ooty recently, and has successfully taken over the land used by MRC for conducting races at Udhagamandalam in April-June every year? Also, IVB seems to have been totally stopped there (although I am not sure about it).

The hon'ble Court is likely to go only by facts which clearly look to favour the government and not the race club.