In light of the upcoming Indian Derby, scheduled to be held in February, the current contenders show potential. Santassimo leads the pack, followed by Knotty Legend, African Gold, Redefined , Positano and others. However, none of these horses inspire complete confidence. While someone will undoubtedly win.
This raises a crucial question:- why has there been a decline in the quality of horses in recent times? Trainers appear hesitant to race their wards in multiple events, unlike in the past. This creates the impression that the horses lack the stamina and quality needed for consistent performance.
Gone are the days of intense competition among legendary stallions like Razeen, Placerville, Al Nasr Al Washeek, Diffident, and Burden of Proof. A truly outstanding horse should emulate the likes of Desert God, In the Spotlight, or Juliette. The prevalence of fragile horses today stems from the lack of quality stallions. Can you name a single horse from recent times that has performed consistently? Even the progeny of Multidimensional, such as Immortality, struggle to maintain performance levels after the Derby. Although Multidimensional has produced dependable horses like Alandair, they still do not evoke the same confidence as legends like Al Nasr Al Washeek or Razeen.
Another reason for this decline is timid training approaches. African Gold, for instance, turned out to be a disappointment due to the trainer's lack of confidence in the horse. One can only wonder how successful African Gold could have been under the guidance of Padmanabhan, who might have secured at least two Derby victories with him by now.
12 Replies
Veteran Punter said ...
01-Jan-2025
@Parvati Byramji
Congragullations, Ma/am!
Magnectic is the fourth classic winner you have led in after Gift of Grace, Ravishing Form, and African Gold. What makes it more special is that Magnectic won over the 12-furlong trip, unlike the other three who won the Mile Classics.
Wishing you many more classic successes!
Veteran Punter said ...
30-Dec-2024
@Mrs Parvati Byramji
Ma'am, I reciprocate your New Year greetings in advance.
I am hoping the grin turns into a big smile on New Year's Day if Magnetic were to win the SI Oaks. Personally, I am very confident about her chances.
Veteran Punter said ...
30-Dec-2024
@Abbaas
I do not mind resuming now that Ma'am has responded and gotten the message.
Coming back to your analysis, Abbaas, regarding Santissimo's exceptional performance as compared to the previous siblings.
Well, before I get on that, let me tell you about one vital aspect of breeding. It is the 'nick' factor.
Almost four decades ago, a stallion named TV Sunday had stood at Hargobind Stud Farm, and the show was then run by Tegbir Brar's father, the late Mr. Sonny Brar. I am hoping burly Tegbir Brar is not reading this, as what I am going to state about the offspring of TV Sunday may make him see red. TV Sunday mostly produced duds. Most of his offspring were lethargic and lacked early speed. In racing parlance, such horses are deemed plodders. His barnmate Ilheus was the dominant partner.
But believe it or not, two of his progeny, Chaitanya Chakram and Chaitanya Ratham, were blessed with the terrific early speed, and their classic victories are still ranked high by those in the know. And what was confounding is that they won multiple classics wire-to-posrt, with Chaitanya Chakram going on to win the ultimate race—the Indian Derby. I am digressing now as I have got to say this: you had to be there to witness one of the greatest battles ever fought in the straight between Lloyd Marshal-ridden Chaitaya Chakram, and Capricorn with Vasant Shinde atop. Mind you, Capricorn was by Grey Gaston, who produced four Indian Derby winners prior to his untimely demise.
That got me intrigued, and upon perusing the bloodline, it dawned upon me that the dam, Urvashi, of Chaitanya Chakram and Chaitanya Ratham was by the champion sire Everyday II. It was the nick factor that worked.
Coming back to Santissimo, his dam, Beldon Hill, was crossed for the first time with the now-deceased proven sire Gusto, and in that, produced the champion performer.
If asked, I would attribute it to the 'nick' factor.
Coming to what you are peeved at: African Gold not participating in the Deccan and Mysore Derby.
Tell me, Abbass, which trainer does not aspire to lead in a Derby winner?
That question should suffice to dispel your wrongly-presumed motive for African Gold not participating in the Deccan and Mysore Derby.
Let me be frank with you, the same thought did cross my mind, but upon perusing the bloodline of African Gold, I realised it had serious stamina limitations.
See you next year, have a blast tonight, and welcome the New Year with a positive frame of mind.
Parvati Byramji said ...
30-Dec-2024
@ veteran punter - Thank you . You genuinely made me grin .
What punters may no know is this , license holders under all race clubs i.e trainers , jockeys , assistants etc , come under the rules of racing .
Therefore we are contractually not allowed to discuss any racing , or retaliate in any manner in order to defend our position. It is the same reasons we ( jockeys or trainers ) do not react to the shouting of the public , in any way " unbecoming of a professional " . And we can actually be held accountable by the authorities for our words and actions .
We can only thank people when they are kind to us . And hope to do better with regards to training in the future to those who find fault . Thank you and happy new year to all
Veteran Punter said ...
29-Dec-2024
@Abbass
You may be feeling ignored for not replying to you. Well, I am desisting from doing so, as Mrs. Parvati Byramrji, the trainer of African Gold, has interacted, and if I were to say anything more, it may sound like buttering. I will see too it that we carry on on some other topic whenever such topics come up in the future.
Until then, we shall take a break.
So long,
VP
Veteran Punter said ...
29-Dec-2024
@ Mrs Parvati Byyramj
I am taken aback by your acknowledgement, as seldom do we see the professinals interact with the lesser mortals of racing—the punters—in this forum. You have enriched this forum with your gracious presence.
Well, I guess you must be busy preparing your likely third classic winner, Magnetic, in the SI Oaks, scheduled to run two days hence.
I say likely because the field lacks in depth, and your ward, although by a speedy sire, Magnetic can do it on sheer class alone. If she has inherited stamina from her dam, she could make it a pillar-to-post affair with speed from her sire and the stamina from her dam to keep going until the post.
Good luck to you, Ma'am, and I hope to see you beaming while leading in Magnetic day after tomorrow.
Ram said ...
29-Dec-2024
@veteran punter,
I agree with you when you spoke about bloodlines,but till prasanna should us Gusto can stay everyone thought they were good for sprints.
Even I thought the same, when the horse was doing so well they could have taken chances in hyderabad or Mysore derby where the competition was less.thanks
Precisely_that said ...
28-Dec-2024
The reason is quality of mares exported now as compared to earlier. There is long list which I can put up, but will keep it to two for easy example.
Zaya the dam of Starsky, Yana was a got abroad. But mare bloodlines were strong as well. She was covered by Selkirk a very good stallion when bought by Usha. She dropped a foal in form of Starsky. Who went on to win Indian Derby. Later she produced fillies like Yana. And we know how strong and dominating the bloodline still is.
Other example is Rahy's Serenade. She was covered by Allied Cause and produced a mysore derby winner Allies Serenade. But that was not only foal she produced as good. She later went on with Frida Khalo, Deigo Riveara and so on.
Late me latest of any got abroad mare who has this consistency.
Today its like instant noodles. Get a foal from some fancy stallion, out of mare that breeder abroad is not interested in retaining and if foal goes by sire influence it will win some good races. At times may be even multi classics.
Later the same dam is not even able to produce class 3 winner with local stallions.
Analyze it if anyone has a doubt.
The quality of imports need to improve a lot. And its no ones fault. The stake money, taxation and many other factors bring a financial restriction on pruchase. What will The breeders or agents do. Even they need to keep budget tight.
Parvati Byramji said ...
28-Dec-2024
@Veteran Punter . Thank you for you kind words and excellent analysis . I have done my best by my horse and thank you for acknowledging that . I am truly humbled .
Abbas said ...
28-Dec-2024
Dear Veteran punter, thank you for your detailed reply and for sharing your insights on African Gold's pedigree and performance. However, I believe there are key aspects you may have overlooked, which highlight the confusion in the trainer's strategy.
Firstly, African Gold's trainer skipped the regional derbies (2000m ) despite them being an excellent opportunity to test the horse's stamina. If there were doubts about the horse's ability to sustain longer distances, there was no justification for bringing him to Mumbai and racing him against the best horses during this time. It is common knowledge that any trainer who brings a horse to Mumbai ahead of the Indian Derby usually does so to give the horse a preparatory run. This move gave punters the impression that African Gold was being prepared for the Indian Derby. If the trainer had concerns about stamina, the horse should never have been brought to Mumbai in the first place.
Secondly, African Gold had already convincingly won races over 1600m with many runs in the past, yet failed in the same distance. This inconsistency raises questions about the trainer's strategy and preparation rather than the horse's ability or bloodline.
While pedigree plays a crucial role in a horse's performance, exceptions often occur. For instance, Santassimo's dam, Belden Hill, produced 7-8 horses, none of which succeeded over 2000m except Santassimo. Similarly, African Gold has outperformed his siblings, demonstrating that he is an exception within his bloodline. Comparing him to Fontana is irrelevant given African Gold's superior record.
Finally, while I respect your perspective and experience, the trainer's inconsistent decisions appear confusing and reflect a lack of clear strategy. It's essential to consider these aspects when evaluating a horse's performance and potential.
Veteran Punter said ...
28-Dec-2024
@Abbass
Your posting headline sounded the genuine concerns of the punters who are getting beaten blue and black on almost all race days. I was expecting something sensible, but your last paragraph exposes your lack of bloodline of a horse.
You have chosen to criticize the so-called timid approach of the trainer of African Gold. Well, my friend, let me tell you with confidence that you are completely off the mark on that.
You ought to have praised the trainer of African Gold for winning two classics. The reason being that only African Gold is the lone classic winner of the eight racing-named foals of his dam. So that statement of yours against the trainer was totally uncalled for.
Another reason is your lack of pedigree and performance. The dam, Kerataka, of African Gold never won beyond the 1200m. As such, African Gold has stamina limitations.
For your information, Kerataka was trained by Pesi Shroff, and one of her foals, Fontana, until recently was under his care, and he never could get him to perform beyond the 1400m distance races.
So get your facts before posting.
Kishore Mukherjee said ...
28-Dec-2024
Your concern is worthy but your aspect is wrong. Its not decline in horse pedigree or their stamina.
The reason is during 90's or 20's or even till 2019 winning any event was prestigious matter for owner n trainers n even jockeys . But now a days its not.
Recently The way African Gold and Psyhic Star surrender in Mumbai to Santissimo in event like Guinea and same way the way Trakila did to Rise And REIGN in Kolkata Oaks or the way Agnostic did to Black Eagle clearly shows that its not fault of the animal.It have been scripted n manipulated by brains of trainers n owners.
Santissimo is good horse but if you watch video again n again you will find both African Gold n Pshyic star just did not even tried ...They just let him go...But fact is these two horses are far better than the winner n if in original race Santissimo will be beaten 9 times out of 10 by these two horses. Same stands for Agnostic and Trakila.
So when money matters most than how can you question standard of poor animal. The main concern which these trainers n owners should be of that how many more days such racing punters will be able to tolerate. This industry is always throne of eyes for many but if owners n trainers don't put their greediness down n do major events on merit very soon this industry will be tear in pieces.