Much to my astonishment..... I found in Race no 6 (Mumbai 09.01.25) horse no 4 MARIELLA the daughter of Planetaire - Caressed.... is at rating of 21.... And will be running at 54 kgs ..... after getting an allowance of 5 kgs
It's a gross mistake by the Mumbai race club?
9 Replies
Prinit said ...
10-Jan-2025
@Ashok..very true. Must be the case...
Jp said ...
09-Jan-2025
Mariella rating and weights appear to be handicappers mistake.
Except, Precision, Yuletide and Mariella the rest 3 had their last run in Class 4 and now running a class down . The weights allotted to them is as per rating. Since Mariella had been given a rating of 21 and how God only knows has been given appropriate weights.
Lot of things are stated in race day reports and it is seldom implemented. I have seen bleeders being prohibited to run for a stipulated time but they have run within that period. Reports stating starting gate practice required is also not followed in many cases.
Ashok Deb Chowdhury said ...
08-Jan-2025
Mr. Prinit, in the case of Brave Beauty... It might have happened that the trainer Mr. Hosider Daji has given an undertaking that as because his horse had won 5 races in 1400....1600....and 2000.... so to win a 1200m race she requires a slow start .....
Ashok Deb Chowdhury said ...
08-Jan-2025
It cannot be a mere printing mistake.... The number of the horse is 4 .....so the prescribed weight has to be equal or more than horse number 5.....
Legally MARIELLA should run with 50 kgs ..... and after allowance it should be 45 kgs....
So either this said race has to be cancelled or number 4(MARIELLA) will not be permitted to run....
Prinit said ...
08-Jan-2025
Here is another one. Brave Beauty planted and lost many lengths at the start, vas advised a mock race. Still running tomorrov vith no record of it running in any mock race.
R.srinivasan said ...
08-Jan-2025
Mr Ashok is correct. There is no possibility for a horse which was board out last outing with rating 1 to get 21 rating. May be printer`s devil
Sarat Sharma said ...
08-Jan-2025
1. The rating of a horse has nothing to do with weight of a horse.
2.MARIELLA has been running at the low rating of 1 since NOV 24 , end of Pune season, the mare has slid down in ratings in her career being a non winner and has only placed twice in lowest class. Many such horses are racing in our country, nothing strange about that. if ever she wins maybe she will get penalised by 10 or 12 points, or else she can race at a zero rating also.
Pepps said ...
08-Jan-2025
I am not knowing anything about how rating got raised but I know that at 356 kgs. Mariella is most likely lightest horse in training. Will be much obliged if someone can mention any horse which is weighing less.
Precisely_that said ...
07-Jan-2025
Ya you are right. Previous rating for horse was 1. Don't know how suddenly got raised by 20 points without winning or placing.