The handicapped kept Time & Tide at the same rating 126 because, the horse did not give any new information to him.It has more to do with the quality of the opposition. May be on a day when a horse rated comparatively level challenges Time & Tide ,the handicapper may increase the rating.
Coming to the point raised by @ Precisely....may be a sprinter will not be able win over Derby distance ,but there is no reason why a quality stayed will not be able to win over a sprint.
In 1989/90, Exhilaration won Indian Derby as well as Invitation Cup in Mumbai.He made his reappearance in a 1000 meter Race in Pune.In a field which had quality sprinters he was installed as a favourite (90/100 )..The tipsters were unanimous in their opinion that "the horse should complete the formalities".The Hindu remembered the old jargon " A quality stayed, after a long layoff should win over ANY distance "
The very next season ,I was witness to Star Contender winning a Class 1 sprint ,2000 guineas ,Derby ,and St.Leger in the Bangalore Winter.
@ Godzilla, Ratings have to be understood in their proper context.A 126 rated horse will not be able to beat a zero rated horse in a handicap race( If the zero rated horse carries 50 kgs ,126 rated horse will have to carry 88 kgs --- an impossibility !